‘Standard candle’ supernova extraordinarily magnified by gravitational lensing

Figure 1: Schematic illustration of the magnification of PS1-10afx. A massive object between us and the supernova bends light rays much as a glass lens can focus light. As more light rays are directed toward the observer than would be…

Figure 1: Schematic illustration of the magnification of PS1-10afx. A massive object between us and the supernova bends light rays much as a glass lens can focus light. As more light rays are directed toward the observer than would be without the lens, the supernova appears magnified. Credit: Kavli IPMU

A team of researchers at the Kavli IPMU led by Robert Quimby has identified what may prove to be the first ever Type Ia supernova (SNIa) magnified by a strong gravitational lens. In this work, the ‘standard candle’ property of Type Ia supernovae is used to directly measure the magnification due to gravitational lensing. This provides the first glimpse of the science that will soon come out of dark matter and dark energy studies derived from deep, wide-field imaging surveys.

The supernova, named PS1-10afx, was discovered by the Panoramic Survey Telescope & Rapid Response System 1 (Pan-STARRS1). PS1-10afx exploded over 9 billion years ago, which places it far further than typical Pan-STARRS1 discoveries. Based on this distance and its relatively bright appearance, the Pan-STARRS1 team concluded that PS1-10afx was intrinsically very luminous. The inferred luminosity, about 100 billion times greater than our Sun, is comparable to members of a new, rare variety of superluminous supernovae (SLSNe), but that is where the similarities end.
SLSNe typically have blue colors, and their brightness changes relatively slowly with time. PS1-10afx on the other hand was rather red even after correcting for its redshift, and its brightness changed as fast as normal supernovae. There is no known physical model that can explain how a supernova could simultaneously be so luminous, so red, and so fast.


Figure 2: The light curve of PS1-10afx compared to a normal SNIa. The blue dots show the observations of PS1-10afx through a red (i-band) filter, which corresponds to ultra-violet (UV) light in the rest frame of the supernova. The red squares show UV observations of the nearby SNIa, 2011fe compressed slightly along the time axis to match the width of PS1-10afx in its rest frame. The dashed lines show a fit to the SN 2011fe data and this same curve shifted by a constant factor of 30. The good agreement with the PS1-10afx data shows that PS1-10afx has the lightcurve shape of a normal SNIa, but it is 30 times brighter than expected.

Soon after the findings were announced, Robert Quimby, a postdoctoral researcher at Kavli IPMU, independently analyzed the data. Quimby is an expert in SLSNe and has played a key role in their discovery. He quickly confirmed part, but not all of the conclusions. PS1-10afx was indeed rather distinct from all known SLSNe, but the data struck Quimby as oddly familiar. He compared the features seen in the spectra of PS1-10afx to known supernova, and, surprisingly, found an excellent match. The spectra of PS1-10afx are almost identical to normal SNIa.
SNIa have a very useful property that has enabled cosmologists to chart the expansion of our Universe over the last several billion years: SNIa have strikingly similar peak luminosities that can be rendered even more standard by correcting for how quickly they brighten and fade (their “light curves”). This property allows astronomers to use SNIa as standard candles to measure distances, as was key to the discovery of the accelerating expansion of the Universe (2011 Nobel Prize in Physics).


Artist’s conception of TypeIa Supernova. Credit: Kavli IPMU

How does the light curve of PS1-10afx compare to SNIa? After correcting for time dilation (another consequence of our expanding Universe), the light-curve of PS1-10afx is perfectly consistent with a SNIa, but the observed brightness of PS1-10afx is far too high for such a distant SNIa (see Figure 2).

To understand this mysterious discovery, Quimby tapped into cosmologists and mathematicians at Kavli IPMU, including Marcus Werner who specializes in mathematical theory of gravitational lensing, and found an explanation: the anomalously high brightness could indicate that PS1-10afx was gravitationally lensed by an object between us and the supernova. While light travels through space in “straight” lines, massive objects warp space and thus cause rays of light to “bend” around them. Thus if there is a sufficiently massive object aligned between us and PS1-10afx, light rays that would have gone off to other parts of the cosmos will be focused on us, making PS1-10afx appear brighter (see Figure 1). This does not change the colors or spectra of the lensed object, nor does it change how fast the supernova evolves. The supernova simply appears brighter than it would otherwise, just as was observed for PS1-10afx. In this case, the lensing object may be detectable even after the supernova has faded away; future observations may thus provide final confirmation of this scenario.
This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
The Kavli IPMU team’s identification of the first strongly lensed SNIa is unprecedented but not entirely unexpected. Masamune Oguri, one of the co-authors on Quimby’s team, led a paper a few years ago predicting that Pan-STARRS1 was capable of discovering strongly lensed SNIa. He has also shown that such objects may be exploited to place precise constraints on the cosmology of the Universe. Now that Quimby’s team has shown how to identify them, next generation surveys with the Hyper Suprime-Cam on Subaru Telescope and the planned LSST can be tuned to discover even more strongly lensed SNIa. These discoveries can be used to study the nature of dark matter, test theories of gravity, and help reveal what our universe is made of.

More information: Quimby, R. et al. Extraordinary Magnification of the Ordinary Type Ia Supernova PS1-10afx, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 768:L20 (5pp), 2013 May 1. Published online on April 18, 2013. doi:10.1088/2041-8205/768/1/L20

Journal reference:

Astrophysical Journal Letters

Provided by

The Kavli Foundation

view popular

4.7 /5 (7 votes)

Related Stories

Pan-STARRS finds a ‘lost’ supernova

Mar 07, 2013

(Phys.org) —The star Eta Carinae is ready to blow. 170 years ago, this 100-solar-mass object belched out several suns’ worth of gas in an eruption that made it the second-brightest star after Sirius. That …

Pan-STARRS discovers two super supernovae

Jul 22, 2011

Supernovae are the brightest phenomenon in the current universe. As massive stars die as supernovae, they briefly outshine the rest of the stars in their galaxy and are visible, at least once the light gets …

‘Cosmic mirages’ confirm accelerated cosmic expansion

Apr 11, 2012

(Phys.org) — An international team of researchers led by Masamune Oguri at Kavli IPMU and Naohisa Inada at Nara National College of Technology conduced an unprecedented survey of gravitationally lensed quasars, …

Pan-STARRS discovers its first potentially hazardous asteroid

Sep 27, 2010

The Panoramic Survey Telescope & Rapid Response System (Pan-STARRS) PS1 telescope has discovered an asteroid that will come within 4 million miles of Earth in mid-October. The object is about 150 feet in diameter …

Recommended for you

Mysterious hot spots observed in a cool red supergiant

1 hour ago

(Phys.org) —Astronomers have released a new image of the outer atmosphere of Betelgeuse – one of the nearest red supergiants to Earth – revealing the detailed structure of the matter being thrown off …

Study finds white dwarf stars may hold the key to detecting life on other planets

8 hours ago

(Phys.org) —Because it has no source of energy, a dead star—known as a white dwarf—will eventually cool down and fade away. But circumstantial evidence suggests that white dwarfs can still support habitable …

Rare galaxy found furiously burning fuel for stars

Apr 23, 2013

Astronomers have found a galaxy turning gas into stars with almost 100 percent efficiency, a rare phase of galaxy evolution that is the most extreme yet observed. The findings come from the IRAM Plateau de …

Universality of circular polarization in star- and planet-forming regions: Implications for the origin of homochirality

Apr 23, 2013

A research team with Jungmi KWON (GUAS/NAOJ) has performed deep imaging linear and circular polarimetry of the ‘Cat’s Paw Nebula’ (NGC 6334) located in the constellation Scorpius, successfully detecting high …

User comments

Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.

Display comments: newest first

More news stories

Scientists detect dark lightning linked to visible lightning

(Phys.org)—Researchers have identified a burst of high-energy radiation known as ‘dark lightning” immediately preceding a flash of ordinary lightning. The new finding provides observational evidence that …

NASA chief: Visiting an asteroid is all agency can afford

A NASA plan to send astronauts to an asteroid was met with skepticism Wednesday when NASA Chief Charlie Bolden presented the idea to top space officials in Congress – though their doubts may not be enough …

Mysterious hot spots observed in a cool red supergiant

(Phys.org) —Astronomers have released a new image of the outer atmosphere of Betelgeuse – one of the nearest red supergiants to Earth – revealing the detailed structure of the matter being thrown off …

Study opens possibility of more dynamic biological oxygen cycle on early Earth than previously supposed

A research team of biogeochemists at the University of California, Riverside has provided a new view on the relationship between the earliest accumulation of oxygen in the atmosphere, arguably the most important …

Ancient Earth crust stored in deep mantle

Scientists have long believed that lava erupted from certain oceanic volcanoes contains materials from the early Earth’s crust. But decisive evidence for this phenomenon has proven elusive. New research from …

Using microbubbles to improve cancer therapy

Microbubbles decrease the time and acoustic power of ultrasound required to heat and destroy an embedded target, finds research in BioMed Central’s open access journal Journal of Therapeutic Ultrasound. If these results can be …

New battery design could help solar and wind power the grid

(Phys.org) —Researchers from the U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory and Stanford University have designed a low-cost, long-life battery that could enable solar and wind …

Just what makes that little old ant… change a flower’s nectar content?

Ants play a variety of important roles in many ecosystems. As frequent visitors to flowers, they can benefit plants in their role as pollinators when they forage on sugar-rich nectar. However, a new study …

Discovery of wound-healing genes in flies could mitigate human skin ailments

Biologists at UC San Diego have identified eight genes never before suspected to play a role in wound healing that are called into action near the areas where wounds occur.

Study suggests clenching right hand may help form memories, left may help recall words

Clenching your right hand may help form a stronger memory of an event or action, and clenching your left may help you recollect the memory later, according to research published April 24 in the open access …